War of the Roses (《玫瑰战争》)
TVB Jade (StarHub Ch838, Singtel Ch511), Mondays to Fridays, 8.30pm
Also available on Hub Drama First (StarHub Ch860), Starter+ and the TVBAnywhere+ app

Framed and branded a homewrecker, drugged and forced to entertain, shot on set after a prop gun is replaced with a real one… Dramas exploring the dark side of show business rarely lack talking points or generate little buzz. TVB anniversary drama War of the Roses, which attracted attention even before its premiere, is no exception.

Jointly produced by Tencent Video and TVB, the 25-episode crime thriller is adapted from TVB actress Momo Wu’s novel Victoria’s Party (《维多利亚的派对》). Set in the entertainment industry, it combines a female-led revenge story with suspense, and stars Tavia Yeung, Moses Chan, Rosina Lam, Kenneth Ma, Ruco Chan, Elaine Yiu, Kelly Fu, Yoyo Chen and Judy Kwong.

The drama follows actresses Xia Wushuang (Tavia Yeung) and Guan Ziying (Yoyo Chen), who become friends before finding fame and pursue their dreams in the film industry together. Guan wins a best actress award shortly after her debut, only to be dogged by bad press and a series of misfortunes. She eventually falls into the sea and disappears.

Seven years later, Guan is declared legally dead. Among her belongings, Xia discovers a diary and learns to her horror that her friend’s suffering was orchestrated by their former close friends — actresses Li Qiyun (Rosina Lam), Liang Feiya (Kelly Fu) and Lin An’an (Judy Kwong), and top talent agent Lan Fengyi (Elaine Yiu). She vows to secure justice for Guan.

Xia makes a commanding return as the Asia-Pacific representative of a French film studio. Using talks with Tiancheng Entertainment boss Chen Yunsheng (Moses Chan) over a remake of the classic film Rose (《玫瑰》) as bait, she plots to get close to the four women, setting in motion an increasingly intense psychological battle.

Tavia Yeung (left) and Rosina Lam (right) resume their battle of wits in War of the Roses after starring in 2024’s Darkside of the Moon (《黑色月光》).(From the drama’s Weibo account)
Tavia Yeung (left) and Rosina Lam (right) resume their battle of wits in War of the Roses after starring in 2024’s Darkside of the Moon (《黑色月光》).(From the drama’s Weibo account)

Revenge plot strains credibility

The drama’s head writer, Fong Sai-keung, is a veteran of Hong Kong film and television who spent his early career writing film scripts. In recent years, he has worked mainly with chief producer Chung Shu-kai on productions such as crime investigation drama D.I.D. 12 (《刑侦12》) and police thriller No Room for Crime (《反黑英雄》). Moving away from his familiar terrain of tough-guy stories, Fong seems less assured with a female-led revenge drama such as War of the Roses. In the first four or five episodes, frequent flashbacks make for jarring transitions between past and present, leaving the narrative somewhat disjointed.

Some of the revenge schemes also fail to withstand scrutiny. They are not just blunt and simplistic; protected by her protagonist’s plot armour, Xia exacts revenge far too easily. A diary she happens to find on the living-room floor of Guan’s former home conveniently tells her how her close friend was harmed and who was behind it. Xia even manages to bribe stunt crew members to tamper with the wires used during filming, causing Li — who had a hand in harming Guan — to suffer a heavy fall and injure herself. She also pays Yang Suxi (Jacky Cai) to seduce Liang’s husband, wealthy scion Douglas Ho (Ruco Chan). Such contrivances are rather too simplistic to convince. One can only hope the story improves as it progresses.

Although billed as a crime thriller, War of the Roses appears to have revealed most of the mystery surrounding Guan’s disappearance after jumping into the sea, along with the main reasons she was driven to desperation, within its opening episodes. Unless a major twist lies ahead — perhaps she is still alive and secretly plotting her counterattack, or the apparent masterminds exposed so far are not the real culprits — much of the suspense is lost. The remaining episodes risk becoming a one-dimensional revenge story.

Before her fall into the sea, newly crowned best actress Guan Ziying, played by Yoyo Chen (left), had a romance with faded star Li Delong, played by Kenneth Ma (right).(From the drama’s Weibo account)
Before her fall into the sea, newly crowned best actress Guan Ziying, played by Yoyo Chen (left), had a romance with faded star Li Delong, played by Kenneth Ma (right).(From the drama’s Weibo account)

Award-winning stars command the screen; Rosina Lam and Kenneth Ma shine in the details

The principal cast certainly deliver. Following 2024’s Darkside of the Moon, Tavia Yeung once again plays a “revenge queen”. Whether her eyes are red and brimming with angry tears as she recalls the wrongs her friend suffered, her voice and gaze carry a veiled challenge, or she puts on a practised social smile while navigating the world of fame and fortune, she strikes the right notes. Still, one hopes she can move beyond the mould of Darkside of the Moon and offer a more adventurous performance as the story unfolds.

Rosina Lam takes a restrained approach to Li Qiyun, the entertainment company’s leading actress. In contrast to her more demonstrative performance in Darkside of the Moon, her Li is reserved and calculating. Every word and action is carefully considered; only her eyes betray what she truly feels in the moment.

Moses Chan, meanwhile, has the commanding presence of an entertainment company boss from his first appearance as Chen Yunsheng. Whenever Guan is mentioned or comes to mind, a fleeting sadness crosses his eyes. This subtle touch hints at their past connection and leaves viewers keen to discover more.

Kenneth Ma plays faded star Li Delong, who is both Chen’s younger brother and Guan’s secret lover. In a scene where he receives Guan’s belongings, memories of their time together overwhelm him with grief, and he breaks down in tears of self-reproach. Ma makes the scene deeply affecting, fully conveying the character’s guilt and heartbreak.