Chinese state media has pushed back against talk of a “deflation trap”, “overcapacity” and “China shock 2.0”, declaring that “those who talk down China’s economy will ultimately be proved wrong”. But against a backdrop of persistent stock market declines, the article has met a public backlash, highlighting the gap between the official macroeconomic narrative and people’s everyday experiences.
The app of People’s Daily, the Chinese Communist Party’s flagship newspaper, published a commentary on Saturday (21 November) titled “Those who talk down China’s economy will ultimately be proved wrong!” (《唱空中国经济者终会落空!》). It said some overseas media outlets and institutions had repeatedly attacked China’s economy this year, hyping claims about a “deflation trap”, “overcapacity”, “China shock 2.0” and “spillovers from China’s economic crisis”. They were “using ‘China’s collapse’ to undermine confidence and the ‘China threat’ to impose restrictions and containment”, it said.
The article argued that some of these pessimistic assessments extrapolated temporary difficulties into a systemic crisis, while others conflated concepts, portraying competitive advantages as threats to the world. Still others started with a predetermined conclusion, repeating the same pessimistic claims regardless of how China’s economy developed.
It gave these examples: “When economic growth slows, they say the growth model is unsustainable; when the economy keeps growing, they say growth relies too heavily on policy stimulus. When exports come under pressure, they question the competitiveness of Chinese manufacturing; when exports perform strongly, they attribute it to overcapacity and insufficient domestic demand. Either way, they reach a negative conclusion.”
The article did, however, acknowledge that China faces problems including pressure on the property market, strong supply but weak demand, and concerns over consumer confidence. Still, it stressed that “those who talk the economy down will ultimately be proved wrong, while those who get on with the work have a bright future”.
Xu Tianchen, a senior economist at the Economist Intelligence Unit, told Lianhe Zaobao that the article was a single response to recent external views on China’s economy. “Its main target is the tendency to politicise China’s economic problems, rather than a denial of the challenges facing the economy.”
The phrase “those who talk down China’s economy will ultimately be proved wrong” trended online in China on Saturday, but Chinese internet users widely linked it to the country’s persistently falling stock market. China’s major stock indices continued to weaken this week, with turnover on the Shanghai and Shenzhen exchanges falling midweek to its lowest level in more than 16 months.
Several financial bloggers posted comments such as: “It’s not about talking the market down — we’ve lost everything.” Another wrote: “If you have what it takes, make the market rise and show them. Bankrupt everyone shorting China!”
Another internet user wrote: “Those who believed in China’s economy, kept adding to their investments, took out mortgages to buy homes and borrowed to trade stocks — patient retail investors — are suffering the biggest loss of wealth in their lives… Those shorting A-shares with three-times leverage are making money hand over fist. People’s Daily, how am I supposed to believe you?”
Xu said investors’ complaints did indeed stem partly from the weak stock market. But the pullback in Chinese equities was also affected by a global technology bear market. The tech-heavy US Nasdaq index plunged nearly 6% on Friday (20 November), and China’s market could hardly remain unscathed.
He said: “The official economic narrative emphasises long-term, structural and strategic achievements, while the public is more concerned with short-term, tangible changes in their personal economic circumstances. The two are not contradictory, nor can we say that one is right and the other wrong.”
Reuters cited analysts as saying that China’s weak economy was a key reason for the lack of confidence among stock market investors, and that expectations were rising for policies to stabilise the economy and markets.
China’s economic growth slowed across the board in October. Industrial, retail and investment figures released on Monday (16 November) all fell short of expectations, while exports continued to grow strongly.
Song Yu, chief China economist at UBS Securities, said that even strong export figures were not enough to offset weakness in China’s domestic economy. He expected Chinese policymakers to take more administrative measures to ensure that year-on-year growth in the fourth quarter remained stable compared with the third quarter.