The second online auction of jewellery confiscated in the S$3 billion money laundering case ended on Sunday (22 November). The 188 lots fetched a total hammer price of S$9,208,010, about 64% above their combined high estimates of nearly S$5.61 million. Two jadeite necklaces commanded the highest hammer prices, fetching a combined S$2.85 million.
Hotlotz founder and chief executive Matthew Elton said all 188 lots were sold, marking the third consecutive sale in the auction series with no unsold lots. He said the result reflected Singapore’s emergence as an important market for fine jewellery auctions.
Bidding in the online auction, conducted by auction house Hotlotz, closed progressively after 4pm on Sunday.
According to Lianhe Zaobao’s calculations, 146 of the 188 lots fetched hammer prices above their high estimates.
One of the most closely watched lots was Lot 102, a jadeite cabochon and diamond pendant necklace. It attracted 72 bids before selling for S$1.75 million — the highest hammer price of the auction and about 4.6 times its high estimate of S$380,000.
The necklace features a jadeite cabochon measuring 39mm long and 31mm wide, with diamonds weighing about 30.36 carats in total set throughout the chain.
Lot 85, a similarly designed jadeite and diamond necklace with a slightly smaller jadeite cabochon, attracted 62 bids and sold for S$1.1 million, or 2.75 times its high estimate of S$400,000. Its diamonds weigh about 10 carats in total.
Not all lots exceeded their estimates, however. Four fetched hammer prices about 21% to 28% below their respective low estimates. Three were jadeite pendants carved in the likeness of Guanyin or Maitreya Buddha, while the fourth was a Cartier diamond bangle with visible scratches on its outer surface.
The opening bid for each lot in this series also serves as its reserve price. If a lot opens at S$1,000 and only one person bids that amount, that bidder wins the item.
Why are buyers willing to pay above second-hand market prices?
Feng Yixian, chief curator and director of Singapore pre-owned fine jewellery dealer WLCSG, told Lianhe Zaobao that, after adding the 20% buyer’s premium, the hammer prices of some widely available branded jewellery pieces exceeded the second-hand market prices she had observed.
She cited Lot 109, a Panthère de Cartier necklace featuring a panther pendant set with diamonds, emeralds and onyx, which sold for a hammer price of S$26,000. Including the buyer’s premium, the buyer would have to pay S$31,200. She said she had seen the same model selling for about S$14,000 to S$20,000 on the second-hand market.
Asked why some buyers were willing to pay more for these lots, Feng said bidders might not be seeking bargains or hoping to profit from resale, but were instead drawn to the unusual stories behind the jewellery. For some collectors, taking part in an auction linked to the high-profile money laundering case was an attraction in itself.
She said some customers who had participated in the previous auction were also following this sale. One had told her it was interesting to be part of this piece of “criminal history”.
The first auction of confiscated jewellery ended on 27 September, with 286 lots fetching a total hammer price of S$5,010,350.
Three more auctions of luxury goods confiscated in the money laundering case are scheduled: a sale of Hermès handbags and accessories closing on 26 November, a luxury watch sale on 29 November and a spirits sale on 1 December.