Bangladeshi work pass holder Ripon Chowdhury recently sparked an online controversy. He first posted a video on social media calling for a uniform minimum monthly wage of $2,000 in Singapore. After the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) decided not to renew his work pass, an online petition emerged urging the ministry to reconsider. The incident has exposed a regulatory gap in Singapore’s governance that urgently needs to be addressed.

While the Public Order Act and the Foreign Interference (Countermeasures) Act can effectively regulate physical assemblies, political sponsorship of local political entities and individuals by foreign funds and foreigners and covert political influence operations, the digital age has enabled foreign work pass holders to launch campaigns on Singapore’s public policies and exert pressure online.

To eliminate legal grey areas, curb such conduct, and protect national policy from online agitation, Singapore must introduce specific legislation explicitly prohibiting foreign work pass holders from engaging in online political advocacy and public policy campaigning.

Singapore’s acceptance of foreign workers rests on mutual responsibilities. On the one hand, migrant workers enjoy stringent statutory protections under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act, oversight of their accommodation, and timely payment of wages. On the other, the state retains absolute sovereignty over domestic policymaking and work pass conditions.

The incident reveals several deeper concerns.

Confusing privileges with rights: A work pass is an economic privilege granted to a foreigner at the state’s discretion, not a political platform. Bypassing internal company channels to air demands on social media, organising online petitions and demanding a public explanation from MOM effectively turns migrant workers into political agitators.

Misconstruing union membership: Demands that the National Trades Union Congress (NTUC), or the Migrant Workers’ Centre it established, “step forward” to overturn MOM’s administrative decision stem from a fundamental misunderstanding of the system. Union membership provides workplace safety support and representation in wage disputes. It does not exempt foreign workers from national work pass approval rules, nor can it compel unions to challenge national sovereignty.

Undermining macroeconomic management: Pushing for a blanket wage mandate through online videos disregards Singapore’s carefully calibrated management of its industries under the tripartite framework comprising MOM, NTUC and the Singapore National Employers Federation (SNEF). Allowing foreign workers to influence policy through social media pressure would also undermine hard-won industrial harmony.

Employers are directly responsible for managing foreign work pass holders and form the first line of defence against labour disputes spilling into the public domain. They must coordinate efforts in three areas.

Clarifying workplace and social media boundaries: Employers, such as major marine and construction companies, must provide direct guidance on the legal distinction between prohibited policy advocacy and legitimate workplace feedback. This would ensure that companies closely integrate their standard social media policies with work pass conditions.

Strengthening internal human resources channels for resolving issues: The legislation must work in tandem with companies’ internal operational feedback mechanisms. Involving organisations such as SNEF can ensure that the law requires companies to establish internal human resources channels through which workers can lawfully raise concerns, removing any excuse for taking them to social media.

Handling administratively required departures discreetly and properly: Employers need clear regulations to guide them in providing private, orderly support for departures and appeals when work pass applications or renewals are rejected. This would prevent administrative matters from becoming public controversies on online petition platforms.

NTUC must be closely involved in the tripartite drafting of legislation

Given the labour movement’s crucial role in maintaining industrial harmony, NTUC must be involved throughout the legislative consultation process.

Distinguishing rights protection from political advocacy: As a core tripartite partner, NTUC must help define the legal boundaries between protected workplace rights (such as reporting safety hazards, unpaid wages or abuse through MOM and the Migrant Workers’ Centre); and prohibited policy advocacy (such as campaigning for broad wage reforms or launching public petitions targeting MOM).

Providing guidance and counselling on the ground: Union officials on factory floors, in shipyard branches and in company unions are best placed to counsel foreign union members directly. NTUC’s involvement can ensure that the law empowers union representatives to curb agitation at an early stage and educate foreign members that union protection can never override national immigration laws.

Channelling constructive feedback internally: NTUC’s involvement can ensure that practical suggestions from foreign workers on living costs are incorporated into formal tripartite mechanisms, such as the National Wages Council or sectoral reviews of the Progressive Wage Model, rather than developing into online agitation.

Singapore welcomes foreign workers to help build the country, earn a living and contribute to national development. However, their purpose in Singapore is to work, not to stir up disputes, make political demands or incite discontent against the government.

A law prohibiting foreigners from engaging in online political advocacy would close the existing legal gap and leave no room for ambiguity. Directly involving SNEF and NTUC in legislative consultations and drafting would strengthen internal corporate accountability, consolidate tripartite consensus and ensure that the power to govern the country remains firmly in Singaporean hands.

(The writer is a retired manager.)