The mainland Chinese officials who welcomed Taiwan’s Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ representative Stan Shih on his arrival in Shenzhen were of a different rank from those at the 2014 Beijing summit. Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council said it was reasonable for mainland officials handling the relevant affairs to receive him, as APEC is an international meeting, but acknowledged that Taiwan was unhappy with some details of the reception arrangements.

According to Taiwan’s United Daily News (《联合报》) and China Times (《中国时报》), the Acer Group founder arrived in Shenzhen on Wednesday (18 November) to attend the APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting the following day.

The mainland sent Cheng Lie, a counsellor in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ Department of International Economic Affairs, along with officials from the Guangdong provincial and Shenzhen municipal APEC preparatory committees, to receive him. Cheng’s rank is roughly equivalent to that of a division director or deputy director-general.

By contrast, when Beijing hosted the APEC summit in 2014, Taiwan’s leaders’ representative, former vice-president Vincent Siew, was received by Chen Yuanfeng, then deputy director of the mainland’s Taiwan Affairs Office, a vice-ministerial official.

Asked about the differences in the ranks and departments of the officials receiving Taiwan’s representatives on the two occasions, Mainland Affairs Council deputy minister and spokesman Liang Wen-chieh said at a regular press conference on Thursday (19 November) that APEC was an international meeting, not cross-strait talks. It was therefore reasonable for mainland officials responsible for APEC affairs to receive the delegation without Taiwan Affairs Office officials taking part. “I think this is reasonable,” he said.

However, Liang acknowledged that Taiwan was not entirely satisfied with some details of the mainland’s reception arrangements, although they were acceptable overall. He did not specify which arrangements had caused dissatisfaction.

He stressed that Taiwan’s participation in APEC itself demonstrated its place in the international community. “There are some aspects we are unhappy with, but we can still accept them.”

Taiwan’s delegation had earlier said that although the mainland officials receiving it were below the ministerial rank Taiwan had hoped for, checks with other economies confirmed that they had received the same treatment. The arrangements were therefore still acceptable.