South Africa’s government says Taiwan has ignored its demand to move its representative office from the administrative capital, Pretoria, to Johannesburg, leaving the two sides deadlocked in a three-year diplomatic dispute. Taiwan maintains that the office will continue operating at its current location until an agreement is reached.

Bloomberg reported on Tuesday (17 November) that South African Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola said in a written reply to a parliamentary question that the office was still operating in Pretoria despite several measures taken by his government. These included unilaterally downgrading Taiwan’s representative office in July last year and renaming it the “Taipei Commercial Office”.

Lamola said the building housing Taiwan’s representative office still bore the “Taipei Liaison Office” sign, and the office continued to enjoy privileges such as tax exemptions. He stressed: “The decision to instruct the Taipei Commercial Office to relocate is non-negotiable”, calling it a “logical and political imperative”.

Bloomberg previously cited officials from Taiwan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs as saying that South Africa began pressing Taiwan to relocate its representative office as early as 2023, after hosting a BRICS summit attended by Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Responding on Tuesday, Taiwan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman Hsiao Kuang-wei said Taiwan had consistently taken a pragmatic approach in its dealings with South Africa. He urged South Africa to act as a democracy governed by the rule of law and not attempt to use local authorities to force Taiwan to relocate its office.

Hsiao said Taiwan had recently sent a formal reply to South Africa’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, offering specific proposals on how to conduct consultations. Taiwan hoped both sides would begin rational discussions as soon as possible to find a suitable solution. Until an agreement was reached, however, Taiwan’s representative office would continue operating in Pretoria.

Lamola said the South African government was consulting the City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality, which includes Pretoria, to find a “legally sound and diplomatically appropriate” way to enforce the relocation demand without triggering litigation or an international dispute.

However, Taiwan owns the building housing its representative office, and constitutional protections for property rights in South Africa limit the government’s ability to force a relocation.

The dispute has also affected trade and economic ties. In September last year, Taiwan announced export controls on 47 products destined for South Africa, including chips and other critical components needed by the country’s automotive and technology industries. Taiwan subsequently suspended the measures after South Africa agreed to begin formal talks.

More than a year later, negotiations have yet to produce a breakthrough. Lamola said South Africa was continuing to push for the signing of a new memorandum on bilateral arrangements to govern trade, investment and cultural relations. It also hoped to end a situation in which Taiwan continued to disregard the South African government.