Minutes of Malaysia’s Federal Pardons Board meeting show that board member Hannah Yeoh Tseow Suan, the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department responsible for Federal Territories, and Attorney-General Mohd Dusuki Mokhtar both opposed granting a conditional pardon to former prime minister Najib Razak. However, Malaysia’s King Sultan Ibrahim, who has the final say on pardons, ordered them to sign the pardon order.

According to Sin Chew Daily, the minutes of the Federal Pardons Board’s 64th meeting, previously classified as an official secret, were declassified and released as the Attorney General’s Chambers proceeded with the case involving the Malaysian Bar’s challenge to Najib’s pardon.

The minutes show that the meeting to discuss Najib’s pardon application was held at 8.30am on 18 September at the National Palace, chaired by Sultan Ibrahim. Both Yeoh and Mohd Dusuki argued that Najib should remain in prison until August 2028 to complete his reduced sentence in the case involving SRC International, a former subsidiary of 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB).

Mohd Dusuki explicitly opposed allowing Najib to serve his sentence under house arrest, saying that existing laws contained no provisions for it.

He also said allowing Najib to serve his sentence under house arrest would affect the government, particularly by undermining domestic political stability, economic development, foreign investor confidence and Malaysia’s international reputation.

However, he said that although Malaysia’s legal system lacked specific legislation on house arrest, Article 42 of the Federal Constitution empowered the King to grant pardons, reprieves and commutations of sentences. He would therefore abide by the King’s final decision.

Yeoh said she shared Mohd Dusuki’s views. Yeoh, who is also the Democratic Action Party (DAP) Member of Parliament for Segambut in Kuala Lumpur, stressed that she had consistently opposed a pardon for Najib.

Following the discussion, Sultan Ibrahim decided to grant Najib a conditional pardon. Najib would only need to pay his RM50 million (S$15.7 million) fine in full to serve the remainder of his sentence under house arrest.

Sultan Ibrahim asked Yeoh to sign the conditional pardon order. She politely declined and suggested that Chief Secretary to the Government Shamsul Azri Abu Bakar sign in her place. Sultan Ibrahim said, however, that Shamsul Azri was not a Pardons Board member and was therefore not an appropriate substitute.

He added that signing the pardon order was part of Yeoh’s duties as the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department responsible for Federal Territories, and would also confirm her attendance at the meeting. Yeoh then signed the conditional pardon order as instructed.

Former DAP Member of Parliament Tony Pua uploaded the minutes to Facebook on Wednesday (18 November). However, UMNO, the party to which Najib belongs, questioned whether royal consent had been obtained to declassify the document and accused Pua of acting in a manner tantamount to incitement.

UMNO information chief Azalina Othman Said issued a statement asking the authorities to clarify whether the document had been lawfully declassified, who had authorised it and whether the material released was complete.

Azalina, who is also the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department responsible for Law and Institutional Reform, said UMNO also wanted the government to explain the procedure under which the minutes had been declassified and the purpose of doing so.

UMNO secretary-general Asyraf Wajdi Dusuki issued a separate statement accusing Pua of circulating the minutes on social media in an attempt to stir controversy over the King’s pardoning powers.

He stressed that royal consent should have been obtained before the minutes were released, as the King chaired the Federal Pardons Board meeting.