A chicken flying across a road has led to an unusual lawsuit. A motorist braked suddenly to avoid hitting the bird, prompting a private-hire driver behind to do the same. A female passenger who claimed she was injured as a result sued the private-hire driver for negligence, but lost her case.
District Judge Jonathan Ng Pang Ern found that the private-hire driver had not breached his duty of care and was therefore not liable to compensate the passenger. He stressed that the incident, triggered by a chicken flying across the road, was one of life’s unpredictable mishaps. The law does not require people to bear legal responsibility for every unforeseen accident in life.
The judge said: “In an imperfect world, some losses must lie where they fall.” He also ordered the passenger to pay the driver’s legal costs of $15,000, plus GST and reasonable disbursements. The passenger has appealed to the High Court against the ruling.
According to the judgment released by the State Courts this week, the incident took place on 19 February 2024 along Holland Road.
The claimant, Chen Qianyun Yvonne, was a passenger in a private-hire car driven by the defendant, Tan Teng Kiat. Chen said a wild chicken suddenly appeared in the lane, while Tan said it was a rooster that flew across the road into the path of the vehicle ahead of his car.
The vehicle in front braked suddenly to avoid hitting the chicken, and Tan also braked hard, bringing his car to a quick stop. Chen argued that Tan had failed to keep a proper distance from the vehicle ahead and therefore had to slam on the brakes to avoid a collision, causing her injuries.
Chen sought compensation from Tan, accusing him of negligence and breaching his duty of care towards her as a passenger. The judgment did not disclose the amount she sought or her detailed account of her injuries, although she had told Tan that she suffered back pain after the incident.
Tan maintained that he had been driving at about 50kmh and keeping a distance of about 10m from the vehicle ahead. Chen, however, said the gap was only four to five metres.
The judge noted that, under the Highway Code, Tan should have kept a distance of about three car lengths from the vehicle ahead, so his stated following distance of 10m appeared insufficient at first glance. However, as Tan had successfully stopped without hitting the vehicle, the judge considered that both parties might have underestimated the actual distance and made no finding on this disputed point.
The judge also considered emergency braking a reasonable and necessary response, regardless of whether Tan had maintained a sufficient safety distance, given how suddenly the incident unfolded. It would have been unrealistic to expect Tan to brake normally and bring the car to a gradual stop in such an emergency. He therefore found that Tan had not breached his duty of care and was not legally liable for the incident.
The judgment also revealed that, after the incident, Chen had initially asked Tan whether he had seen the registration number of the vehicle ahead and whether he would be willing to testify for her, as she was considering suing its driver. The judge noted that Chen appeared to have subsequently changed her mind and sued Tan instead.
Apart from this case, Chen has also brought civil claims against two drivers over at least two other traffic accidents, which occurred in 2022 and 2024. She was also a passenger in those incidents. The courts have ruled in her favour in both cases, with the amounts of compensation yet to be determined.