As soon as the traffic lights turn red for vehicles, Joo Chiat Road becomes a “mini Shibuya”, with pedestrians streaming across from every direction while vehicles wait. On the first day of a trial of an all-way pedestrian crossing at the junction of Joo Chiat Road and East Coast Road, residents interviewed welcomed the more flexible crossing arrangements, although some worried about confusion on the roads. Motorists and food delivery riders said a ban on right turns would be inconvenient and could worsen congestion.

The three-month trial at the junction outside i12 Katong mall began on Monday (16 November) afternoon. Pedestrians can cross diagonally, as they do at Japan’s famous Shibuya crossing, as well as straight across.

When Lianhe Zaobao visited on Monday, diagonal guide lines had been marked on the road, while traffic lights facing pedestrians crossing diagonally and signs had been installed at the corners. Several auxiliary police officers were also directing traffic, keeping pedestrian and vehicle movements separate.

The pedestrian crossing phase was observed to last about 35 seconds, during which vehicles in all directions faced red lights and many people began crossing diagonally. Pedestrian and vehicle traffic was moderate in the afternoon. Some people filmed the diagonally positioned traffic lights as they crossed, while some cyclists crossing diagonally had to avoid pedestrians coming from another direction.

Student Fu Wantong, 17, said: “This is an interesting initiative, but the junction is very small, so it certainly feels different from Shibuya.”

She also noted that there were many cyclists in the area and worried that those riding across the road might collide with pedestrians.

Resident Fan Xiaoju, a 41-year-old stay-at-home mother, felt the “Shibuya” label could become a Joo Chiat attraction, much like its car-free days, drawing more people to experience it. “Crossing diagonally is also more convenient, as you don’t have to wait for the lights twice.”

A Lianhe Zaobao photojournalist captured Joo Chiat Road’s transformation into “Shibuya” on Monday morning. The new traffic lights face pedestrians diagonally across the junction, guiding them across.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
A Lianhe Zaobao photojournalist captured Joo Chiat Road’s transformation into “Shibuya” on Monday morning. The new traffic lights face pedestrians diagonally across the junction, guiding them across.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)

Some shops along Joo Chiat Road have outdoor seating, leaving the pavements relatively narrow. Tang Junyong, 28, an employee at coffee shop Alibabar, said the roadside seats were popular at weekends, but crowds waiting at the traffic lights outside often made the dining area cramped. “Stopping all the vehicles at once to give pedestrians time to cross will be more efficient and safer.”

Right-turn ban on East Coast Road raises fears of congestion from detours

Under the new arrangements, vehicles travelling along East Coast Road towards Mountbatten Road cannot turn right into Joo Chiat Road. Signs prohibiting right turns were put up at the junction that day. The diversion is understood not to affect bus routes. Waiting times for motorists and pedestrians may also be longer.

Ms Li, a freelancer in her 40s who drives from East Coast Road to Joo Chiat Road for meals at weekends, found the right-turn ban very inconvenient. “I have to turn right earlier at Tembeling Road, or drive to the junction at Katong Shopping Centre, where traffic is already very congested.”

Food delivery rider Hamdan Ahmed, 46, said traffic on Joo Chiat Road backed up in the evenings and at weekends from i12 Katong mall to the junction with Dunman Road. Longer waiting times could worsen congestion. Motorist Sun Rui, 43, who is unemployed, also said Joo Chiat Road was busy and parking was difficult, so she usually parked at the mall and walked over.

Workers mark diagonal guide lines for pedestrians at the junction of East Coast Road and Joo Chiat Road on Monday morning.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
Workers mark diagonal guide lines for pedestrians at the junction of East Coast Road and Joo Chiat Road on Monday morning.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
Signs at the junction outside i12 Katong mall alert road users to the all-way pedestrian crossing trial.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
Signs at the junction outside i12 Katong mall alert road users to the all-way pedestrian crossing trial.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)

Khai Haron, 27, who delivers food in the Joo Chiat area, said collecting orders from shops on the western side of Joo Chiat Road would become less convenient. If delivery riders could not plan their routes in advance, some might illegally use the pavement for convenience.

Dean's chair and associate professor at NUS Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Ong Ghim Ping Raymond, said in an interview that all-way pedestrian crossings are generally installed at junctions with heavy foot traffic, strong demand for crossing in multiple directions and frequent interactions between pedestrians and turning vehicles, including in commercial districts, shopping streets and transport hubs.

With its mix of shops, eateries and residential areas, and large numbers of pedestrians throughout the day, the area around Joo Chiat Road was an “interesting location for such a trial”, he said. “Unlike a major arterial junction where vehicular throughput is the primary consideration, this location also serves an important function as a neighbourhood commercial and pedestrian activity centre. A scramble crossing could therefore improve pedestrian accessibility and safety while supporting the area’s walkability.”

Pedestrians begin crossing the junction diagonally after the works are completed.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
Pedestrians begin crossing the junction diagonally after the works are completed.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)

He was “cautiously optimistic” about the trial, noting that for it to succeed, there must be a clear improvement in pedestrian safety and convenience, particularly in reducing conflicts with turning vehicles.

“The additional delays to motorists and any traffic diversion to surrounding roads must remain manageable... The relatively compact junction may also be more suitable for an all-way pedestrian crossing, however, this does not automatically mean that the trial will be successful.”

City lights reflect off the rain-soaked road as pedestrians carrying umbrellas cross diagonally, giving the Joo Chiat junction a hint of Shibuya’s atmosphere at dusk.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)
City lights reflect off the rain-soaked road as pedestrians carrying umbrellas cross diagonally, giving the Joo Chiat junction a hint of Shibuya’s atmosphere at dusk.(Photo: Chia Ti Yan)