More than half of the households that stopped receiving short-to-medium-term assistance under the ComCare Scheme in 2022 returned within three years, with over 40% doing so within a year.

The Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) released its 2026 report on trends in support for lower-income households on Monday (16 November). It showed that 54% of households that stopped receiving ComCare Short-to-Medium-Term Assistance (SMTA) in 2022 returned within 36 months, five percentage points higher than the 49% recorded for those that exited in 2021.

Of the households that stopped receiving assistance in 2022, 43% returned within a year and 50% within two years. Both figures were also higher than the corresponding rates for households that exited in 2021.

The report noted that the increase likely reflects a shift back towards pre-COVID patterns. During the pandemic, MSF exercised flexibility to support more households that experienced temporary shocks to their financial circumstances because of the pandemic.

“Some households in the 2021 exit cohort may have needed assistance only during the pandemic period and were therefore less likely to return to SMTA after exiting.”

Compared with households that did not return to assistance, a higher proportion of those that returned within three years faced multiple challenges. These included having at least one child under six to support and household members with health issues, which affected the number of household members available for work, their employment options and their ability to remain in stable jobs.

SMTA is primarily for individuals or households who are temporarily unable to work, looking for work, or earning low incomes and in need of assistance. Support is generally provided for three to six months and can be extended where necessary. From 2021 to 2025, the median duration of assistance remained at six months.

Asked whether some households had stopped receiving SMTA too early, an MSF spokesperson told Lianhe Zaobao (LHZB) that the ministry recognises that achieving sustained financial stability can take time for vulnerable households, particularly those facing multiple and sometimes overlapping challenges, such as caregiving responsibilities and health issues.

“A household returning to SMTA could have been ready to exit assistance earlier but had a change in circumstances later, for example due to changes in employment, health or caregiving responsibilities. ComCare therefore remains available as a social safety net when families need support.”

The spokesperson said Social Service Offices (SSOs) assess each household holistically based on its needs and circumstances. SMTA can be extended where further support is required, and households may also return to an SSO to have their needs reassessed.

Beyond financial assistance, SSO officers can connect families to relevant government and community support, including employment support, preschool and student care fee assistance, and assistance with medical expenses.

The report also found that households that were able to strengthen their employment after exiting SMTA were less likely to return.

The spokesperson stressed that employment support can help household members build skills, confidence and job readiness. SSOs therefore work with other government agencies, Family Service Centres and community partners to coordinate support and help households stabilise their circumstances as they work towards greater self-reliance.

For households with more complex needs, ComLink+ provides more holistic and longer-term support.

Leaving financial assistance does not mean achieving lasting self-reliance: Academic

Dr Terence Ho, an associate professor and executive director of the Institute for Adult Learning at the Singapore University of Social Sciences (SUSS), said in an interview that vulnerable families’ progress towards a better life and financial self-reliance is often not linear, sometimes involving three steps forward and two steps back.

He said returning to assistance does not necessarily mean a household was prematurely taken off the scheme. Setbacks such as job loss, illness or unexpected expenses could also have plunged them back into financial difficulty.

Dr Ho said that while SMTA is intended to provide short- to medium-term financial support and encourage self-reliance, some families may benefit from continued non-financial support after exiting the scheme. For example, community support and regular check-ins could help families deal with emerging difficulties before these become more serious.

He also suggested further research into whether households that repeatedly apply for SMTA share certain characteristics, and whether more targeted support could help them achieve greater stability.

“Ultimately, the aim should not simply be to help families exit financial assistance, but to enable them to remain self-reliant over time.”

Fewer households benefit from two aid schemes, but total payouts rise

Separately, the report also detailed the scheme’s disbursement of short-to-medium-term and long-term assistance over the past five years. Although fewer households benefited from either programme last year, total government payouts for both schemes rose from the previous year after assistance rates were raised in 2025.

In 2025, 19,473 households received SMTA, down from 20,825 in 2024. Total disbursements, however, rose from S$94 million to S$96 million.

The report noted that both the number of households receiving SMTA and total disbursements in recent years were below 2021 levels. This could reflect some households receiving the support they needed through other government measures, including cash payments under the Assurance Package.

Long-term assistance is primarily for people who have no income or family support because of old age, health issues or disabilities. Most are seniors living alone.

The number of households receiving long-term assistance fell from 3,240 in the previous year to 2,997 last year, while total disbursements rose from S$21 million to S$22 million.

The report noted that both the number of households receiving long-term assistance and total disbursements in recent years were also below 2021 levels. This could be linked to more seniors continuing to work, having greater savings, and stronger government support for seniors in recent years.