A kindergarten teacher hit a five-year-old autistic girl on the back of the head and pulled her by the collar to the centre of her mattress after she sang loudly before nap time. The teacher has been jailed for her actions.

The 59-year-old teacher faced two charges under the Children and Young Persons Act. She pleaded guilty to one charge on Friday (20 November) and was sentenced to three weeks in jail, with the other charge taken into consideration.

To protect the child victim, the court barred the media from reporting any information that could identify the accused or the victim, including the kindergarten where the incident took place.

On 11 April last year, a senior teacher at the kindergarten saw the accused grab a four-year-old boy by both arms and pull him back, and reported the incident to the management. After reviewing CCTV footage, the management questioned the accused, who admitted that her behaviour was inappropriate.

Six days later, on 17 April, a parent complained to the kindergarten that the accused had handled a child roughly. An investigation did not establish that this amounted to child abuse. However, while reviewing CCTV footage to investigate the complaint further, the kindergarten discovered that the accused had abused another child, a five-year-old girl.

The girl has autism spectrum disorder and literacy challenges. She is usually well-behaved in class and sometimes sings, talks to herself or uses other self-soothing mechanisms.

Investigations showed that at 1.30pm on 8 April last year, the girl was lying on a mattress at nap time, singing loudly as she usually did before going to sleep. The accused entered the room to check on the children. As she approached the girl, the child covered her face with both hands.

The accused then struck the back of the child's head twice with the back of her hand. When the girl turned away from her, she grabbed the girl's collar and pulled her back to the centre of the mattress before leaving the room.

Although the girl complained of pain, she had no visible injuries and showed no obvious signs of emotional distress.

The kindergarten informed the girl's parents on 22 April, and they subsequently made a police report. The accused was later dismissed by the kindergarten.

The prosecution sought six to eight weeks' jail, pointing out that the accused had struck a child with special needs who was singing to soothe herself to sleep. Her offence came to light only by chance, when the kindergarten reviewed the footage over a separate complaint.

In mitigation, the defence lawyer said his client was extremely sensitive to sound and did not understand that the girl's loud singing was a coping mechanism. It was the first time she had heard the girl sing at such a high volume and such a high pitch. Overwhelmed in that moment, she made an error of judgement. The lawyer urged the judge to consider the psychological stress she was under at the time and impose only a fine.

The lawyer also said the accused had subsequently received a warning from the Early Childhood Development Agency but had not been barred from teaching. She was still teaching in an open environment.

In sentencing, State Courts Judge Huang Chunxian said there was no evidence linking the accused's psychological condition to the offence, so it was not a mitigating factor. The victim was autistic, and even if she was particularly loud, the accused, as a teacher, had no reason to hit her, regardless of how sensitive she was to sound. A fine was therefore inappropriate, and a jail term was necessary.