A growing number of US high school students are using artificial intelligence (AI) to write university application essays and shortlist institutions, but admissions rules have failed to keep pace with its adoption. Universities are racing to draw up guidelines on AI use, with some even starting to use it to review applications, sparking debate over fairness in admissions and whether application essays are still necessary.
CNN reported that universities are stepping up efforts to establish rules on AI use as the 1 January deadline next year for the Common App university application platform approaches. Standards, however, vary between institutions.
Pallie, director of undergraduate admissions at the California Institute of Technology, said students were adopting AI faster than university admissions offices could draw up rules.
Caltech allows students to use AI to brainstorm ideas for their essays, but considers it unethical to replace their own distinctive voice and expression with AI-generated content.
Yet universities themselves are also beginning to use AI to assist with admissions. Large public universities such as Virginia Tech are testing AI tools to cope with huge volumes of applications. The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, however, abandoned automated AI scoring after the growing prevalence of AI-assisted writing made AI assessments of essay quality less useful.
Some universities have even begun dropping essay requirements. Tulane University no longer requires applicants to submit an essay explaining why they want to attend the institution this year. The university acknowledged that concerns about AI were among the reasons for the decision.
The shift has also prompted students to ask: if universities can use AI to assess applications, why can students not use it to write their essays?
Pallie stressed that admissions were not simply a matter of selecting students according to a formula, and that human reviewers remained essential. She believes application essays may become less important in future, while face-to-face interaction could become a more important means of assessment.
AI can, however, also help reduce inequalities in access to information about university admissions. Koppenheffer, chief innovation officer at education consultancy EAB, said that for many families, AI served as an admissions adviser they could not otherwise afford, giving students detailed advice on choosing universities free of charge.
An EAB survey found that 82% of respondents who used AI to help choose universities had used ChatGPT.
A US parent surnamed Wilson used the AI tool Claude to create a spreadsheet for the 22 universities his son was applying to, comparing tuition fees, household income and potential financial aid. This substantially reduced the time spent on research.
Experts say that while AI may undermine the authenticity of application essays, it also makes information about university admissions more accessible to students with limited financial resources. Striking a balance between safeguarding fairness in admissions and making good use of new technology is becoming a fresh challenge for US universities.