The UN convened a meeting in Geneva on Monday (16 November) to discuss whether to launch negotiations on legally binding controls on autonomous weapons. But major military powers, including the US and Russia, are expected to oppose the move, casting doubt over the prospects for the talks.

Reuters reported that rapid advances in artificial intelligence (AI) are increasingly enabling military equipment such as drones, robots, tanks and submarines to attack and kill targets autonomously, without human intervention. Semi-autonomous and AI-assisted weapons have already been deployed in conflicts in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East, raising ethical and security concerns.

The UN meeting will decide whether to begin negotiations on legally binding international rules for lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS).

Although most of the 128 states parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons support drawing up such rules, military powers including the US, Russia and Israel argue that existing international humanitarian law is sufficient to regulate the use of these weapons.

The US favours non-legally binding guidelines and has proposed five years of negotiations. Russia has yet to publicly state its position for this round of talks, but has consistently opposed a legally binding agreement.

The International Committee of the Red Cross, however, believes existing international humanitarian law is inadequate to address the specific risks posed by autonomous weapons.

Human Rights Watch representative Verity Coyle warned that machines must never be allowed to decide who lives and dies on the battlefield, but that this worrying prospect is rapidly becoming a reality.

Advocacy groups also warned that autonomous weapons systems could behave unpredictably, increasing the risk of fatal misjudgements.

Diplomats said this round of talks was expected to be difficult, but participants could still reach a compromise before the end of the week, including a legally binding agreement, a non-binding one, or a combination of both.

The meeting’s chair has proposed two years of negotiations to draw up a legally binding protocol. The UK, Germany and France favour starting negotiations without deciding for now whether the final agreement should be legally binding.