(Brussels/Kyiv) — Ceasefire talks on the Russia-Ukraine conflict are touching on more fundamental questions about Europe’s security architecture. The US is seeking to broaden the talks to cover European security arrangements, including NATO troop deployments, leaving its European allies in a bind.
A Bloomberg analysis noted that European countries risk being shut out of negotiations affecting their own security if they do not take part. But if they opt in, they must face pressure from Russia, which is using the peace talks to demand limits on NATO troop deployments.
People familiar with the matter said US envoys were pushing Russia and Ukraine to discuss NATO rules, military equipment and troop deployments in Europe. They have even asked Kyiv whether it would be willing to cede the Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership.
Europe has consistently maintained that Russia must first agree to a ceasefire before NATO and troop deployments can be discussed. With the US now putting these issues on the negotiating table together, Europe fears Russia could seize the opportunity to reshape the continent’s security landscape.
Sources said Russia wants NATO to pledge not to deploy troops in member states that joined after 1997, and has proposed reducing its military presence in Kaliningrad and Belarus in return. Several EU leaders have already said the proposal is unacceptable.
However, to avoid being excluded from the negotiations, the EU, along with the UK, France, Germany, Italy and Poland, designated national security advisers last Friday (13 November) to take part in follow-up technical consultations.
Some European leaders also suspect Russian President Vladimir Putin is deliberately drawing out the talks, hoping that political shifts after elections in France and other European countries in 2027 will change Europe’s policy towards Ukraine.
Faced with the complex negotiations, Europe and Ukraine have made their positions clear. Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys stressed that Russia has no right to veto Ukraine’s accession to the EU or interfere in NATO troop deployment arrangements.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy urged Europe to send representatives to the talks. He said he was willing to discuss the US security proposals, provided Washington presented a concrete plan to ensure Ukraine could join NATO and the EU and maintain a strong military after the war.
Crimean Bridge hit as fighting continues
As the parties prepared for negotiations, Ukraine used drones and missiles on Tuesday (17 November) to destroy the central road section of the bridge linking mainland Russia to Crimea. The attack killed two people and brought all road traffic across the bridge to a halt. Rail services have so far only partially resumed.
The 19km bridge is a landmark project that Putin inaugurated in 2018. Although Russian forces now rely more heavily on the land corridor through occupied southeastern Ukraine to transport supplies, the attack on the bridge still dealt Putin a major symbolic blow.