The Devil’s Plan: Dead Again
Available on Netflix
South Korean brain-game shows keep raising the stakes. The third season of The Devil’s Plan brings together legends of the mind-game survival genre, with even five-time champion Jang Dong-min joining the fray for the first time. The 16 players have formidable credentials: among them are the winners of the first two seasons and leading contenders from other brain-game competitions. With champions facing champions and masters pitting their wits against one another, the cast list alone is enough to set longtime fans’ pulses racing.
Producer Jung Jong-yeon remains at the helm this season. Having created popular brain-game shows such as The Genius, Society Game, Great Escape and High School Mystery Club, he has now abandoned his usual preference for fresh faces to stage an all-star showdown.
The line-up is certainly impressive. But after watching the first five episodes, I found myself wondering: do more top players necessarily make for a better show?
Who dares take on the five-time champion?
The biggest draw this season is, of course, Jang Dong-min, known as “God Dong-min”.
The 47-year-old comedian has long attained legendary status in survival shows, earning a reputation as the ultimate boss. He won The Genius twice before claiming further titles in Society Game 2, Game of Blood and Bet on Fact, notching up five wins in five outings.
He may usually play for laughs, but once a game begins, he becomes a different person. He has an extraordinary memory and excels at psychological warfare, but his greatest strength is his ability to read people. He knows when to forge alliances and when to strike, and can turn players with conflicting agendas into a team that follows his lead.
This time, he has reunited with Oh Hyun-min, his formidable partner from The Genius. Their seamless teamwork on that show earned them the name “Jang-Oh alliance”. Their reunion naturally puts the other players on high alert. The scheming Jung Won-young sets his sights on them early, determined to break up this formidable duo.
The trouble is that Jang is so strong that even other top players can easily become supporting characters. If he once again leads his allies all the way to the final, the promised clash of titans may turn into a one-man show.
Even the best can stumble
Alongside Jang are Hong Jin-ho, the inaugural winner of The Genius, and Ha Seok-jin and Jeong Hyeon-gyu, the winners of the first two seasons of The Devil’s Plan. It is a rare gathering of four champions.
I was especially looking forward to seeing first-season champion Ha Seok-jin, known for his intellect, prove himself again. His cool judgement and impressive comebacks won him countless fans in the first season. Unfortunately, luck is not on his side this time, and he hits a wall before he can show his full capabilities. Hong Jin-ho also fails to recapture his former brilliance.
As for second-season champion Jeong Hyeon-gyu, his taunting of opponents, coupled with allies sacrificing themselves to clear his path to victory, provoked a viewer backlash at the time. Some even accused the show of turning a battle of wits into a melodrama. This time, he has reined in his arrogance. His quieter, more likeable presence has made me see him in a new light.
Surprisingly, the entertainers I had assumed were there merely to add star power perform rather well. Singer John Park won The Time Hotel, while popular host Jaejae appeared in High School Mystery Club. Super Junior’s Shindong, a regular on Great Escape, often explores his surroundings alone in search of clues, looking every bit the escape-room veteran.
Tougher games, harder-to-read players
The biggest change this season is that players are no longer automatically eliminated when they lose all their Pieces, the game’s tokens. Instead, their survival depends on match results. Movement between the prison and living quarters is also less restricted, giving players more opportunities to confront one another.
The new rules cut out some of the drawn-out elements of the first two seasons, but not every game is compelling. Some rules are dizzyingly complicated, while the roulette game relies too heavily on luck. For what is billed as the ultimate battle of brains, it sometimes feels like watching a group of experts take their chances.
What upset me most was seeing Shindong set up by Jung Won-young. A quick mind, it seems, does not necessarily make someone a good judge of character.
Shindong trusts him completely, never imagining that Jung will exploit that trust step by step to push him towards elimination. Seeing his shock and disappointment when he discovers the truth is genuinely painful.
It brings to mind his Super Junior bandmate Kyuhyun, who sacrificed himself to protect his ally Jeong Hyeon-gyu in the second season and was eliminated as a result. Now Shindong, too, has been undone by someone he trusted. Both bandmates seem too attached to the people around them to be suited to the devil’s game.
Of course, deception and betrayal are part and parcel of survival games, but there are countless ways to win. Choosing to stab the person who trusts you most in the back may be within the rules, but it is still infuriating to watch.
The female players also have relatively little presence. Only four of the 16 contestants are women. Apart from Yurisa, who appeared in Game of Blood and stands out for her distinctive personality, the women have so far had little room to shine.
The Devil’s Plan has assembled some of the best players in the business. The level of brainpower has certainly risen, but the drama has not necessarily kept pace. These experts are so adept at calculating risk that some of the fun of watching things spiral out of control is lost.
After all, the greatest pleasure of survival shows lies not just in watching clever people win, but also in seeing them make mistakes, come unstuck or even be outmanoeuvred by those they trust most.
With “God Dong-min” entering The Devil’s Plan, this battle between god and devil has only just begun. The five-time champion is in position. Who can bring his game to an end? That is the showdown I most want to see.